Italian combo on a fresh roll
Our famous eggplant parm
Stacked high, made to order
The deli case on Prospect Street

Italian Delicatessen · Nutley, NJ · Since 1977

Subs, cutlets& eggplant parm,since 1977.

The old-school Italian deli on Prospect Street: heroes built to order on fresh rolls, hot specials every day, and the eggplant parm Nutley is known for.

Order online Call (973) 667-2959
★★★★★ 4.8 from 241 Google reviews
01

Since 1977

A family deli
on Prospect Street.

Pete’s Delicatessen has fed Nutley since 1977. It started as a family business and the owner, Joe, keeps it in the family: subs built to order on fresh rolls, chicken cutlets fried every day, and the eggplant parm people drive across Jersey for. Old school and friendly, like it’s always been.

“Had to be one of the best eggplant parm I ever had besides my mother’s. Crispy bread, eggplant packed in.”Ron M., Yelp review
4.8Google rating
241Google reviews
1977Established
15classic combos
Behind the counter at Pete’s
Pete’s Delicatessen, 209 Prospect St

The favorites

What Nutley
orders at Pete’s.

Eggplant Parm
01

Eggplant Parm

Our famous eggplant, marinara & mozzarella on a long roll.

$10.50
Italian Combo
02

Italian Combo

Ham, salami & provolone with oil & vinegar.

$11
Chicken Parm
03

Chicken Parm

Fried cutlet, marinara & melted mozzarella.

$11
Fresh Chicken Cutlets
04

Fresh Chicken Cutlets

Breaded and fried fresh every day.

$10
Lasagna
05

Lasagna

Baked fresh in the kitchen.

$12
Pepperoni Bread
06

Pepperoni Bread

Baked in house, sliced to share.

$8
Turkey & Swiss
07

Turkey & Swiss

Piled high on a crusty roll.

$11
Cream Puffs
08

Cream Puffs

Seasonal Italian pastries for the holidays.

Seasonal

Hungry yet?

Start your order
The bread rack

Every morning

Fresh rolls,
cutlets & parm.

Mon–Sat from 8:30 AMTaylor ham, egg & cheeseHot specials daily
Fresh rolls
Fresh rollsShort, long & sesame
Chicken cutlets
Chicken cutletsFried fresh daily
Tomato pie
Tomato pieFrom the kitchen
Olives & salads
Olives & saladsAt the counter

What guests say

★★★★★
“Had to be one of the best eggplant parm I ever had besides my mother’s. Crispy bread, eggplant packed in. Excellent friendly staff, great prices and good food.”
Ron M. · Yelp
★★★★★
“My first ever authentic Italian sub and it was SO GOOD. Came here all the way from Virginia Beach and I can’t wait to go back. The staff was amazing!”
Ana Resendez · Google
★★★★★
“Look at the size of this sandwich! I don’t know how they do it, but this place is absolutely recommended. Talk about bang for your buck, and GOOD!”
Jeff B. · Yelp
★★★★★
“Great old style Italian deli. Everything is home made and delicious. The service is like you’re at home.”
Ralph K. · Yelp
★★★★★
“Amazing deli. Great bread. Old school feel. Italian sandwich and eggplant parm are sooooo good.”
Cleetus J. · Yelp
4.8Google · 241 reviews
4.4Yelp · 87 reviews
1977Family-owned since

Follow along

@petes_deli_nutley

Pete’s Delicatessen postPete’s Delicatessen postPete’s Delicatessen postPete’s Delicatessen postPete’s Delicatessen postPete’s Delicatessen post

Visit us

209 Prospect St,
Nutley, NJ

Hours

SundayClosed
Monday8:30 AM – 4 PM
Tuesday8:30 AM – 4 PM
Wednesday8:30 AM – 4 PM
Thursday8:30 AM – 4 PM
Friday8:30 AM – 4 PM
Saturday8:30 AM – 4 PM
Order online Call (973) 667-2959

On Prospect Street in Nutley · street parking · call ahead for big orders

Map of Pete’s Delicatessen at 209 Prospect St #1, Nutley, NJ 07110Pete’s Get directions →
The deli case

Feeding a crowd?
Trays & party heroes.

Office lunch, game day or a family party: tell us the date and how many people. We’ll call you back to plan it.

Thanks! This demo form isn’t connected yet. Please call (973) 667-2959.